The Captain and the President

On 31 July 2026 Franco Baresi died, and the grief crossed even rival fans. This is not a piece about how great a player he was. It is about what his life tells us about Italy, because it runs parallel to another man's: Silvio Berlusconi. The captain who never spoke and the tycoon who never stopped, who in the same fifteen years and the same city built the same machine, the Milan of the invincibles, and together manufactured the image of a country that believed itself a winner exactly as it began to lose. Thirty years before Trump, the blueprint was written in Milan.

The Captain and the President

How a man who never spoke and a man who never stopped talking built, together, an era of Italy

On 31 July 2026 Franco Baresi died. He was 66, a lung disease, and a funeral at Sant’Ambrogio in Milan with thousands outside, the red-and-black flags, the chant “there is only one captain”. Even the fans of Inter, the rivals of a lifetime, paid their respects. It is the kind of mourning that crosses the factions: when that happens, it means the one who is gone was not only a man. He was the symbol of something that concerned everyone.

This is not a piece about how formidable Baresi was as a player. He was, and many have written of it. This is an attempt to show what Baresi’s trajectory tells us about Italy. Because his life, seen from a distance, runs parallel to that of another man, and together they tell how an era was built: who put in the face, who put in the silence.

The other man is Silvio Berlusconi.

Vienna

Two dreams, one city, the years of lead

Let us go back, to the spring of 1978.

On 23 April, in Verona, a seventeen-year-old boy makes his Serie A debut in the shirt of Milan. His name is Franco Baresi, they call him “piscinin”, the little one. Italy is in the middle of its fifty-five darkest days: Aldo Moro, the country’s most important statesman, has been a prisoner of the Red Brigades for five weeks, and will be killed two weeks later, on 9 May. It is the heart of the anni di piombo, the years of lead, when terrorism and fear were daily bread. And in that frightened country an orphan raised in a peasant family from a village near Brescia makes his debut in football that counts.

He had been turned away. At twelve, Inter had given him a trial and rejected him, too frail. It was his elder brother Beppe who had taken him there, already in Inter’s youth ranks, to keep a promise made to their mother before she died. One taken, the other cast aside. They will become the two opposing captains of Milan, Beppe at Inter, Franco at Milan. The city derby of the 80s is born inside an orphaned family.

In the same months, in the same city, another man is chasing a different dream. He is no longer a boy: Silvio Berlusconi is already forty-two, a wife and two children, a building empire behind him, the residential districts of Milano 2 and Milano 3 built from nothing. He is not a man who starts from the bottom. He is a man who wants to conquer new territory.

That territory is television. And here one must explain something almost no one remembers today. Until a few years earlier, in Italy there was only one television: the state monopoly, two channels, an information world controlled by two parties. Then, in 1976, a ruling of the Constitutional Court opened a crack: private televisions could broadcast, but only locally. Dozens of small regional stations are born, homemade, poor. Berlusconi sees the crack and slips an empire through it. In 1978, the same year as Baresi’s debut, he turns his little cable station, Telemilano, acquired almost by accident against unpaid rent in a building he owned, into a station broadcasting over the air. Two years later he invents the trick that will change Italy: he coordinates dozens of local stations, having them play the same prerecorded tape, the same programmes at the same hour, so each one broadcasts locally, yet all broadcast the same thing at once. The ban on national broadcasting is circumvented. Canale 5 is born. Commercial television in Italy, in effect, is him.

Two dreams that begin at the same moment, in the same city, in the country of the years of lead. But they are not the same dream, and they are not two boys. One is seventeen and has nothing. The other is forty-two and already has much. They have not met yet. And here comes the part that holds up all the rest.

The capital of loyalty

Before Berlusconi arrives at Milan, Baresi has already become a symbol. Alone, and at the worst moment.

The Milan of those years is a club in disgrace. In 1980 it is relegated to the second division by decree, for a match-fixing and illegal-betting scandal: a punishment handed down by judges, not earned on the pitch. Baresi, who had nothing to do with it, could have left. He stayed, and took Milan straight back up. Two years later, in 1982, Milan is relegated again, but this time on the field, on results. And Baresi, who that very summer had just become world champion in Spain without playing a single minute, behind the great Gaetano Scirea, and who had the courtship of Gianni Agnelli‘s Juventus, stays once more. At twenty-two they give him the captain’s armband. He will wear it for fifteen seasons, to his last match.

Let us stop here, because this is the exact point where everything becomes clear. In 1982 Berlusconi is not yet in football. He will arrive four years later. When Baresi decides to stay in the second division for the second time, to bind himself to the fate of a club that had failed twice, to refuse the money and the glory elsewhere, he does it in a Milan that does not yet even have its future president in sight. The symbolic capital of Baresi’s loyalty is deposited before anyone exists who is ready to cash it in.

Then, in February 1986, while Gorbachev announces Perestroika and the Cold War begins to thaw, Berlusconi buys Milan. And he finds the captain already there, already made, already a symbol. He does not create him. He inherits him, and crowns him.

This is the hinge, and it is the heart of everything. Because the story that Berlusconism will tell of itself, the one of conquest and of success built from nothing, needs a face to make it credible. And that face already exists, it is clean and it is true: it is the orphan boy who stayed when he could have fled. Berlusconi does not have to invent Baresi’s loyalty. He only has to climb on top of it.

Frescoed nymph, Pompeii

The revolution and the fig leaf

What comes after is known all over the world, and it must be said with honesty, because it truly was a revolution.

Berlusconi does not merely buy a club. He rethinks it. He brings the money, of course, but above all he brings a new idea of what football can be: total spectacle, limitless ambition, marketing, image. He hires Arrigo Sacchi, an unknown who had coached provincial Parma, against everyone’s advice. He buys the Dutchmen, Gullit, Van Basten, Rijkaard. And the Milan that astonishes the planet is born, the one of pressing, of the offside line raised like a weapon, of football that seems to come from the future. It wins three European Cups and, above all, it pleases. It is beautiful, it is modern, it is winning. Milan’s fans fall in love, the players adore the president who treats them like stars and makes them feel the best in the world. This part is true, and it would be dishonest to deny it: Berlusconi changed football forever, and for the better, for those who worked for him.

But here one must tell the other half, with the same honesty. That Milan is not just a club. It is a shop window. It is the same idea of Italy that Berlusconi sells from the screens of his televisions: modernity, spectacle, success, the aesthetic of victory. The grammar is identical on the pitch and on the air. Milan does not cause political Berlusconism, it would be foolish to say so. But it is the gymnasium where that grammar is trained, the laboratory of a language made of three words: victory, spectacle, belonging. Three concepts that eight years later Berlusconi will carry into politics. It is no accident that the name of his party, “Forza Italia”, was first of all, and first among all, a football-terrace chant.

And inside this shop window, Baresi is the silent pivot. While the Dutchmen are the spectacle, he is the structure: the discipline, the defence, the serious Italian part that holds the operation together. He does not speak, does not shout, does not promise. He plays, commands on the field with a raised arm, and wins. And here is where the true dynamic between the two men shows itself, that of two opposite principles that hold each other up. One is all voice, the other all silence. One sells, the other is. One builds the image, the other the substance. And Baresi’s clean silence becomes, without his wanting it, the fig leaf of the operation: the guarantee of seriousness and honesty upon which a man seduced by power builds his machine of conquest. The captain does not know he is one, but he is the candid part that makes all the rest presentable.

Kroměříž

The prototype

And here the story leaves Italian borders, because what Berlusconi invents in Milan will become, twenty years later, the model of the world.

In 1994 Milan dominates. They are the invincibles of Fabio Capello, with Baresi commanding a defence that conceded just fifteen goals in the whole league season: the title, and a legendary Champions League final, 4-0 in Athens against the dream team of Cruyff‘s Barcelona.

Berlusconi, at the start of that same year, does a thing never seen before: a billionaire who owns the televisions enters politics using those very televisions, presenting himself as the successful businessman who will come and fix a country ruined by professional politicians. These are the years of “Tangentopoli”, the vast corruption investigation that wiped out the entire political class that had governed Italy since the war, and of the dissolution of the Italian Communist Party after the collapse of the Soviet Union. An empty stage, and a man with the screens to fill it.

Silvio wins. He is not a politician who learns to use television. He is a television owner who becomes a politician. He sells himself as the anti-establishment self-made man, the sworn enemy of a caste discredited by the judges and by history, the tycoon who speaks the language of ordinary people against the elites. He promises lower taxes, less state, more freedom, and above all he promises himself: trust me, because you have seen me win.

Does he remind you of anyone?

Twenty years later, on the other side of the ocean, another real-estate billionaire with a second career in television, the star of a reality show rather than the owner of a network, enters politics with the very same script. The businessman who will fix the country, the anti-establishment figure who speaks to the gut against the elites, the character you know because you have watched him on the screen for years and therefore trust. Donald Trump invented nothing. He inherited, and studied well, a manual written in Milan twenty years earlier. Berlusconi himself, when it was pointed out to him, said the comparison was “obvious”. And Trump liked the comparison.

Because the mechanism is the same, and it is the one we wrote about elsewhere: in an age of distrust, people trust those they see a great deal on the screen. A bond forms with someone you do not know but feel you know, because he has entered your home every evening. Berlusconi had understood it before anyone, with his televisions. Trump applied it with the reality show and then with social media. It is the same victory, spectacle, belonging, carried from the football pitch to politics, and from the politics of one country to the politics of the planet. The Milan of the Dutchmen and Canale 5 were the gymnasium. Today’s world is the real match.

Franco is, Silvio sells

There is one last thread that ties Franco and Silvio, and it is the most revealing. But it must be said with precision, because the difference is everything.

Franco Baresi sells nothing. Franco is. He truly comes from the bottom, a peasant’s son, an orphan, cast aside, and he truly did it all by himself, with real sacrifices: the second division chosen twice, the money refused, the loyalty paid for in person. His epic of the boy who rises from nothing is not a narrative. It is his life.

Silvio Berlusconi, instead, sells. He sells everything, including Franco’s epic. And he sells his own too, but his is another story, more ambiguous. Because Berlusconi does not come from nothing at all: he comes from a well-off family, from an already established building firm, from capital whose first origins were never entirely clarified. And yet, and here one must be fair, there is a piece of his story in which the “from the bottom” is authentic: the televisions. There, in the virgin market of commercial television, Berlusconi truly built something that did not exist, he risked, he invented, he won against the monopoly of the state. There the dream that becomes reality is true. The rest is narrative.

And this is why the pair works so well. Baresi is the limpid term that makes the ambiguous one credible. If the captain is true, if his figure is authentic, then the rest of the operation seems genuine too. The clean champion acts as guarantor, without knowing it and without wanting to, for the president’s myth. The ambiguity is all on one side alone. This is the difference to commit to memory.

There is a detail, finally, that closes the circle. In 2020, asked to name the five most important people of his career, Baresi answered: Rocco, Rivera, Liedholm, Berlusconi, Sacchi. He placed the president in his own personal pantheon. The silent captain acknowledged, with gratitude, simplicity and without malice, the man who had built an empire upon his silence.

Forte Marghera

What remains

Berlusconi died in 2023. Baresi in 2026. They leave in the order that helps to read the history: first the man who spoke, then the silent captain who had guaranteed its clean part.

And they leave while the Italy of which they were standard-bearers has now passed. They were not its only symbols, of course: the 1980s and 1990s were a thousand things and a thousand faces. But they were two of the faces of a certain story, that of a country that saw itself rising, modern, winning, rich. “Milano da bere”, the Milan-to-be-drunk of the advertising slogans, glittering and carefree. On the pitch everything was being won. In the country the losing was quietly beginning, and it would last a whole generation and more.

The point is that this story was, in large part, a fine tale well sold. Because while Italy admired itself in Milan’s European Cups and in the lights of Canale 5, it was piling up the bill it would pay in all the years to come, and is paying still. In the 1980s the public debt nearly doubled in proportion to GDP, a rate of increase devastating for a developed country. The glittering wealth, in short, was largely borrowed from those not yet born. And then came the two decades in which Berlusconi moved from football to politics, and the results, this time, were the opposite of the sporting ones: in 2001 he signed, live on television, a “contract with the Italians” in which he promised a million new jobs. They never came in the measure promised; indeed, during his last term the number of employed actually fell, according to the national statistics office.

And the reckoning arrived in 2011. Franco had not played for a long time; he had first coached the youth teams, then, for the celebrations of the twenty-five years of the Berlusconi era, he had been named official ambassador of the club. Milan won the last title of the Berlusconi era, the first since 2004, and Franco took part in the celebrations, as a symbol. But it was 9 November that taught Italians a new word: spread. The gap between Italian and German government bonds shot to levels never seen, the sign that the markets no longer trusted the solidity of Italy’s accounts, now a step from bankruptcy. Three days later, Berlusconi, prime minister for his fourth and last term, resigned. It was not the vote of the Italian people that removed him, a people that in large part had loved him for twenty years, and in smaller part went on loving him afterward despite everything. He was removed by the numbers, the same ones the glittering tale had kept hidden to the very end. A technocrat came, Mario Monti, to make the painful cuts that a man obliged to please the crowd had never been willing to make. The man who had built everything on pleasing the public fell at the exact moment when reality stopped letting itself be told as a story.

Why, then, did the mourning for Baresi cross even the hearts of his adversaries? It is not only respect for a great player. It is that with him dies one of the last clean witnesses of an era otherwise questionable, and today much diminished. Baresi was the genuine part of that story, the part one could love without reservation, even as an enemy. And to mourn him, in the end, is to mourn something greater than a man. It is a country’s grief for its own youth, for the pristine version of itself that it believed true and winning, and that we now know to have been, at least in part, a debt contracted with the future.

The captain did not speak. Perhaps that is why, in the end, we all loved him.

🎧

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top